Book Review: Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud
Book Review: Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud
By Alex M.
••
civilization
• 0 views
Book Review: Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud
Introduction
Have you ever wondered why, despite all our progress—safer cities, better medicine, more entertainment, more freedom—so many people feel anxious, guilty, and unfulfilled? Sigmund Freud asked this question in 1930, and his answer remains one of the most provocative diagnoses of modern life ever written.
Civilization and Its Discontents is a short but devastating essay that argues: civilization protects us from each other, but in doing so, it turns us against ourselves.
This isn't a self-help book. Freud offers no solutions, no ten-step program to happiness, no meditation app. Instead, he presents a tragic vision: that human happiness and social order are fundamentally incompatible, and that this tension is permanent.
Nearly a century later, his diagnosis feels more relevant than ever.
The Central Question
Why are humans so unhappy in civilized society?
Freud's answer is brutal in its simplicity:
Civilization requires us to give up our basic instincts, and that repression inevitably produces guilt, anxiety, and misery.
We build societies to protect ourselves, to create order and safety. But the very mechanisms that make civilization possible—laws, moral codes, social norms, family structures—demand that we suppress our deepest desires. And those desires don't disappear. They turn inward, where they fester and poison us from within.
What Freud Means by "Civilization"
When Freud talks about civilization, he's not just talking about technology or art. He means the entire apparatus of social control:
Security, Secrets, and the Future of Engineering Jobs
Order
Cooperation
Survival
But these goals come at a psychological cost that we rarely acknowledge.
The Problem: Instinct vs. Society
At the heart of Freud's argument is a fundamental conflict between what we are and what society demands we be.
Humans are driven by two powerful instinctual forces:
1. Eros (The Life Instinct)
Sex
Love
Pleasure
Creativity
Bonding
2. Thanatos (The Death Instinct)
Aggression
Violence
Destruction
Cruelty
Self-sabotage
These drives are not optional. They're hardwired into us. They made sense in our evolutionary past, when survival depended on fighting, reproducing, and competing for resources.
But civilization cannot function if people freely act on these drives.
Imagine a world where everyone pursued sexual pleasure without restraint, where every insult led to violence, where aggression was never held back. Society would collapse overnight.
So civilization does the only thing it can: it represses these drives.
Repression Creates Suffering
Here's the problem: instincts don't disappear when they're suppressed.
They go underground. They transform. They mutate into symptoms.
Freud argues that when we repress our natural drives, we don't become peaceful and content. Instead, we become:
Chronically dissatisfied – always wanting something we can't name
Anxious – sensing danger from forces we don't understand
Depressed – feeling a pervasive sense of emptiness
Guilty – punishing ourselves for thoughts we never acted on
Alienated – feeling disconnected from ourselves and others
Freud's diagnosis is shocking:
Modern people are more psychologically sick, not less, despite all our progress.
We've conquered nature, built skyscrapers, cured diseases, connected the world through technology. But we're more miserable than ever.
Why?
Because every advancement in civilization requires more repression, not less.
The Role of Guilt and the Superego
One of Freud's most important insights concerns the mechanism by which civilization controls us.
Society doesn't just impose rules from the outside. It internalizes them inside our minds as the superego—an inner judge that watches, evaluates, and punishes us.
The superego is ruthless:
It punishes us with guilt even when we haven't done anything wrong
It condemns us for our thoughts, not just our actions
It grows stronger the more we behave morally
This last point is Freud's most paradoxical claim:
The more "civilized" you are, the stronger your guilt.
Think about it: the person who never acts on their aggressive or sexual impulses doesn't feel free. They feel guilty for having those impulses in the first place.
The superego is never satisfied. It always demands more restraint, more sacrifice, more self-denial.
This is why people who seem to be doing everything right—following all the rules, meeting all expectations—often feel the worst. They've internalized civilization so completely that they've become their own prison guards.
Religion and Morality
Freud is famous for his skepticism about religion, and this essay is no exception.
He sees religion as:
A coping mechanism – a way to make suffering bearable
An illusion – a comforting fiction with no basis in reality
A tool of social control – reinforcing moral rules through fear and hope
Religion promises that if we endure our suffering now, we'll be rewarded in the afterlife. It tells us that our repression has cosmic meaning, that God is watching and will judge us.
Freud doesn't deny that religion "works" in a psychological sense. It does help people tolerate the unbearable.
But he insists it's still an illusion.
And as modernity weakens religious belief, people lose this coping mechanism—without gaining any real freedom in return.
Happiness Is Not Civilization's Goal
Freud is brutally honest about something most people don't want to hear:
Civilization's aim is survival and order, not happiness.
Society exists to:
Prevent violence
Enable cooperation
Protect property
Reproduce the species
Pass on knowledge
It does not exist to make you happy.
Freud goes further:
Happiness is episodic – it comes in fleeting moments, not permanent states
Happiness is temporary – it fades quickly, no matter what we achieve
Happiness is fragile – it depends on circumstances beyond our control
Most importantly:
Permanent happiness is incompatible with social life.
The very things that make us happy as individuals—freedom, pleasure, self-expression, aggression—are exactly what civilization must suppress.
The Tragic Conclusion
So what's the solution?
Freud's answer is bleak: there isn't one.
He argues that:
Civilization is necessary – without it, life would be even worse (violent, short, chaotic)
But civilization will always frustrate human nature – there's no way to reconcile our instincts with social demands
There is no final solution – only trade-offs and compromises
Human life, according to Freud, is defined by:
A permanent tension between what we want and what society demands.
We can adjust the balance. We can make civilization more or less repressive. But we can never eliminate the tension itself.
This is the source of our discontent.
And it's permanent.
Why This Book Still Matters
Nearly a century after Freud wrote it, Civilization and Its Discontents feels more relevant than ever.
It speaks directly to contemporary experiences:
Burnout – the exhaustion of constantly performing a role
Alienation – the sense of being disconnected from authentic life
Sexual repression – even in a "liberated" age, we still feel guilt and shame
Moral anxiety – the constant fear of being judged or canceled
Political conflict – the struggle over how much freedom vs. control we should have
The paradox of progress – "everything is easier, but nothing feels better"
Freud helps us understand why:
More wealth doesn't make us happier
More technology doesn't make us freer
More sexual liberation doesn't eliminate guilt
More individualism doesn't cure loneliness
Because the problem isn't out there. It's built into the structure of civilization itself.
Final Thoughts
Civilization and Its Discontents is not a comfortable book. It offers no hope, no redemption, no path forward.
But it does offer something valuable: clarity.
Freud forces us to confront a truth we'd rather avoid:
The price of civilization is permanent psychological suffering.
You can accept this and stop searching for a final solution.
You can recognize that the tension between freedom and order, between desire and duty, between self and society, is not a problem to be solved.
It's the human condition.
And once you see that, you stop blaming yourself for not being happy enough, productive enough, fulfilled enough.
You realize: this was always impossible.
And in that realization, perhaps, there's a kind of freedom.
One-Sentence Summary
Civilization protects us from each other, but in doing so, it turns us against ourselves.
Want to explore further? Consider how Freud's insights connect to Nietzsche's critique of morality, Marx's theory of alienation, or Jung's vision of individuation. Or examine how social media has intensified the very tensions Freud diagnosed—creating new forms of guilt, surveillance, and performative identity. The conversation Freud started in 1930 is far from over.